Submit Questions Or Articles For Discussion

Why get only the part of a discussion and comments that a given news site is willing for you to see? Every news site seems to be guilty of censuring comments that “offend” it, with no transparency of its adherence of capriciousness in excluding or deleting comments the editors simply find too ideologically uncomfortable to their agenda.

If it’s on-topic, properly documented, factual and logically reasoned, avoiding crude language (and doesn’t violate copyright or other laws), then IJN will put it in front of your eyes.

What miso-Judaic PC is TV news or print media spinning about Yi•sᵊr•â•eil or Yᵊhud•im now? ABC? BBC? CBS? CNN? France24 (English)? NBC? Yet another Fox (Christian News?) host pushing Christian / Catholic symbols or celebrations in-your-face on non-Christians on public property again? “Occupied territories”? Is an Israeli or Jewish news outlet (Ynetnews, Jerusalem Post, Israel National News (Arutz Sheva), haAretz, Jewish Weekly, etc.)? Article in print media (newspapers, magazines, etc.) off-the-rails about some topic of Ta•na”kh, Ha•lâkh•âh, Yi•sᵊr•â•eil, Yᵊhud•im or relating to the non-Jewish world?

Miso-Judaism in American foreign policy or election politics relative to Yi•sᵊr•â•eil or Yᵊhud•im? Shortcomings in American, European, Israeli or other counter-terror strategy against Muslim Jihadist terrorism? Israel security, foreign policy and relations with the Christian world. American foreign policy vis-à-vis Yi•sᵊr•â•eil, e.g., moving the American embassy from Tel Aviv to Yᵊru•shâ•layim. Perversion of prohibiting Yᵊhud•im from praying on Har haBayit! Report of Yᵊhud•im discriminated from living in an area because mᵊzuz•ot are prohibited? Report of pro-Islam indoctrination in American elementary school books or university courses? What about divisions in the global and Israeli Jewish community; Ultra-Orthodox / Kha•reid•im vs Orthodox and non-Orthodox? How should Yᵊhud•im interface with the rest of the world, historical facts and science, including Christianity vs the Judaic Mâ•shiakh (Mâ•shiakh Bën-Yo•seiph and Mâ•shiakh Bën-Dâ•wid)? Mi•tzᵊw•ot and Ha•lâkh•âh: medieval or logical? Is prohibition of electricity or writing on Shabat valid Ha•lâkh•âh? Is it Rosh ha-Shân•âh beginning the year or Yom Tᵊru•âh in the middle of the year? Qitniyot (legumes & beans) during Khag haMatz•ot? Swinging a chicken on Yom haKi•pur•im? Some verse of Ta•na”kh you have a question about?

For the logical and scientific perspective on interpreting Ha•lâkh•âh, ask the Nᵊtzâr•im your question, suggest a topic, copy the URL of an article you’d like to discuss, etc. into a comment (below). You can include questions or a tweet-size description of your interest in the article. (If the article is posted, you can comment there.)


52 thoughts on “Submit Questions Or Articles For Discussion

  1. Is there an alternate fruit that can be used in place of the Etrog? The crop was affected by a freeze and a shortage is predicted of 80% which means I may not be able to get one.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Update: 2017.08.20
      “New research from Tel Aviv University reveals that citrons and lemons were clear status symbols for the ancient Roman ruling elite…,” not growing wild and abundant as I had conjectured. This research asserts that all citrus arrived in the Middle East too late to be the Biblical “פְּרִי עֵץ הָדָר” (fruit of ‘the splendorous [i.e., citrus] tree,” wa-Yiqra 23.40) refers to the אֶתְרוֹג (etrog; citron). Whereas until now researchers admitted they didn’t know and conjectured citrus, now we must continue to admit we don’t know but that research suggests that, in Biblical times, it was not citrus! My guess, pomegranate.

      Although I discount the usually-cited European Medieval rabbis as too far removed from both Biblical AND modern understanding of authentic Torah, Talmud Bavli (Seider Moeid, Tractate Sukah, p. 35, side a) specifies that “פְּרִי עֵץ הָדָר” refers to the אֶתְרוֹג (etrog; citron); and that dates back to the 5th century C.E. So authenticity and faithfulness to the most ancient documentation, which is the top priority in restoring the pristine תורה term, הדר (citrus, splendor, majesty), that would be recognized from Avraham through Ribi Yᵊhoshua is well-settled: אֶתְרוֹג.

      On the other hand, even the most strict Ultra-Orthodox Jews have lost all touch with authenticity when it comes to horseradish, salt water, celery or lettuce in the Pesakh Seider. So, substituting any citrus fruit can be no worse than what even the strictest Orthodox do in the Seider. In such matters, the Nᵊtzarim are more strict about adherence to ancient Torah authenticity than any Ultra-Orthodox.

      But availability in the Diaspora is not the same as availability in the Sinai and here in Israel. These substitutions seem to all track back to some shortage or inability in the Diaspora to obtain the authentic item – not unlike your dilemma. What’s ok (substitutions of something similar when the authentic is unavailable) for them to do is ok for you to do.

      Almost certainly, in the same way that dandelion and Syrian oregano were originally used in the Pesakh Seider because they grew wild widely and abundantly in the Sinai and Israel, so that every family could simply go out and pick some freely, the אֶתְרוֹג was probably the citrus equivalent, growing wild widely and abundantly in the Sinai and Israel in Biblical times. These were popular items in wide usage by the people in Israel; not odd, foreign, hard-to-get items. By contrast, in the Diaspora where the אֶתְרוֹג does not grow wild nor is widely abundant, other citrus fruits may be more accessible, making them the Diaspora equivalent of the authentic אֶתְרוֹג.

      Taking all of this into account, however, Jews celebrate such things in a community of at least 10 persons; a minyan (which requires appointing a Beit Din). So whatever the Beit Din of the minyan decides should dictate your choice in such matters.

      Most critically: in any case, if circumstances make it reasonably necessary a use substitute then, in future years, when the אֶתְרוֹג again becomes available, restoring authenticity is the priority, NOT establishing yet another local “tradition” to blindly follow like the Ashkenazim, and even Sᵊpharadim have done with horseradish, celery, salt water, etc. since at least the European Dark Ages and Medieval times.

      Celebrate Sukah as authentically as you reasonably can and enjoy!

      Bi-vᵊrakhot ha-Torah,
      Paqid Yirmᵊyahu

      Liked by 1 person

    • Modern Orthodox practice is generally standard Orthodox practice, simply giving priority to Ribi Hileil over Ribi Shamai (as the Ultra-Orthodox exaggerate to extremes). If you don’t find exceptions in our website (, then Ribi Hileil Orthodox practice (contrary to Christian idolatry, Ribi Yᵊhoshua’s teachings followed Ribi Hileil) is the נְצָרִים practice as set forth in our website — with which you should have a working familiarity. For the standard Orthodox practice, you can search the topic online and look for the answer given by the Virtual Jewish Library and, where they differ, follow Ribi Hileil rather than Ribi Shamai.


  2. שלום פקיד my wife and I are looking to bein Israel for the Hoildays is there accomidation in Raanna.


    • We haven’t looked into hotels, hostels or B&B but once or twice since 1983. So we haven’t been in that loop and, consequently, I can be of only limited help as follows.

      Most tourists come in sponsored groups where they’re herded around as a group. This keeps them pretty safe and they see most of the things that most are interested in; and all while staying and eating in nice places and traveling directly to and from sites from a-c buses that know where they’re going and don’t lose the limited time being lost and unable to find their destination. But it also means that Jewish groups avoid Xn sites (99% a good thing) and Xn groups stick exclusively to churches and the like while remaining as blissfully ignorant of sites primarily of interest to Judaism as they were before they came. You’d be better off staying home and save the money than touring with a Xn group.

      If you come in a Modern Orthodox (or other Jewish group guaranteeing כשר accomodations) you’ll be WAY better off. Don’t, under any circumstances, come with a Xn group.

      If you don’t come in a tour group, getting around and finding places while avoiding trouble spots, especially if you don’t speak some עברית, will, at times, be challenging or, if you get lost, may even be extremely dangerous.

      So, I recommend joining a Modern Orthodox Jewish (or Jewish group guaranteeing כשר accommodations) tour group — and then they need to be not only Jewish, but ensure that you’ll have כשר accommodations — NOT “כשר-style” or simply “Jewish.”

      You don’t have to be an Orthodox Jew to tour with a כשר Jewish group PROVIDED it’s Modern Orthodox, NOT Ultra-Orthodox (חרדי or חב”ד or any black hat), and that you let them know you’ll be compliant with their standards and are eager to learn to emulate how they do things (and you’ll need a כיפה: knitted, not black).

      If you take a cab, I wouldn’t ride with an Arab driver. Their name and picture is prominently displayed in their cab (or they’re not legit). So it’s easy for most to distinguish an Arab name from a Jewish name. I’ve found most Jewish taxi drivers to be honest and helpful. Driving with the meter on is usually more expensive IF (!) you settle the price BEFORE YOU GET IN the cab. Settle this first, OUTSIDE the taxi. (Once you’re inside, then you’re on your way and have no negotiating position. You pay what he insists. Problems are rare and there are people to complain to if it’s unreasonable, but you can avoid the problem by getting the price outside the cab.) There are standard rates and these are better than paying the metered price. You can find out from your host where you’re staying, to phone the nearest taxi stand for you (don’t accept “too busy to phone”), what the standard rate is to wherever it is you’re going. Rates also differ for time of day (rush hour, after 1800, etc.).

      One of the greatest shocks to me when I first visited Israel as an American tourist in 1983 was that there are no motels in Israel. Lacking the copious open space to which Americans are accustomed, Israel is too cramped for space to authorize building of space-devouring motels that cater to a motoring crowd that doesn’t exist here. There are motorists, of course. But in this small country, nearly all business trips conclude with a drive home. So there is neither demand nor space for motels. One is limited to a hotel (expensive), a hostel or a B&B (good deals are good deals but bad deals could be an expensive rip-off; plus, you probably need to speak Hebrew). Accordingly, the only hotels are in bigger cities, especially resort cities. רעננה (Ra’anana) is neither and there is no hotel in רעננה.

      For a plethora of reasons, including avoiding problem areas, I strongly (!) advise that you be sure that you’re staying at a Jewish-owned – not Arab-owned – hotel, hostel or B&B. And realize that Arabs will lie to you about such things. Although it’s illegal, I’ve experienced Arabs lying (to what they thought was a tourist who wouldn’t know, namely me) that their food is כשר. So you need to be able to recognize the term כשר on their sign. Every place that serves כשר food has a כשרות certificate and they are NOT offended when you ask to see it. Every דתי Jew visiting a restaurant for the first time (unless it’s been recommended by their friends) asks to see it as a matter of course. (It’s usually prominently displayed where it can be seen from the front door.)

      One thing you should be prepared for is that if you expect to go to a restaurant on שבת then you won’t find כשר food unless you’ve made some kind of arrangements in advance. You can make arrangements in advance to eat on שבת where you are staying (except maybe, some hostels). All כשר restaurants are closed on שבת. That can make for discomfort on שבת.

      Finally, if you’re coming during a חג you’ll need to make arrangements for any Jewish observances, how to walk to (!) the closest תימני or Modern Orthodox בית כנסת. I think, during סוכות for example, every כשר hotel will have a סוכה in which you can eat daily. (So will restaurants, even non-כשר restaurants; so don’t assume a סוכה means it’s כשר.) But hostels and B&B probably will not unless you stick with כשר accommodations (in which case, you’re expected to know כשרות and KEEP it כשר). These kinds of things you’ll need to verify with whatever host you choose, as part of your choice.

      This is all I can think of. Hope it helps and you have a great visit.

      פקיד ירמיהו


  3. Has the Paqid been approached by the frist fruits of zion to merge. Do ffoz recognise the 135post church as authorities?


    • The Nᵊtzarim are a historical part of Torah–moderate Orthodox–Judaism. We don’t entertain overtures of merging with anyone; nor are we interested in recognition from anyone else since all others who claim to be “Netzarim” are phonies and deceivers who have plagiarized the name “Netzarim” from me. The term “Nᵊtzarim” was lost since soon after 135 C.E. and remained unknown until, as part of my research, ha-Sheim showed me–not anyone else–the name and I restored it to use in the early 1970s. There is a considerable number and variety of fakes who are nothing more than self-aggrandizing, Paul-like empire-builders proliferating official-sounding offices for themselves and posing as “Netzarim.” Moderate Orthodox Judaism is legitimate, and the Nᵊtzarim are part of that. All others, including those falsely claiming to be Netzarim–who attempt to set up structures, clerics and titles, or a hierarchy separate from moderate Orthodox Judaism–are phonies and deceivers who are not part of moderate Orthodox Judaism and, therefore, not part of the Netzarim subgroup of moderate Orthodox Judaism.


    • Are we able to claim a filiation with Netzarim or is there more involved? You said and I agree for conversion we must be honest and truth full in what we believe. I or we believe that Yehousua is the Mashiach. Torah living and teaching Rabbi. Called all to teshuva to haShem quodesh echad. As the church of jc did not exist there is no need for coment. So in conclusion there is only 2 shul in Canberra chabad and an orthodox and conservative jewish centre. Purhaps a moderate shul may egistance in Sydney or Melbourne. Or purhaps just continue as we are? Does the Paqid have a view or additional advice?


      • To become a Netzarim, one first must satisfy a moderate Orthodox rabbi that you meet the criteria of “moderate Orthodox Judaism.” That includes everything from keeping Shabat and kashrut to learning how to pray according to proper liturgy–in Hebrew. (For Nᵊtzarim, that’s the Teimani Baladi Sidur–but you’ll probably have to first learn to pray according to Sᵊpharadi liturgy because most Teimanim batei kᵊnesset are peopled by Teimanim so knowledgeable that they have no need of paying a rabbi. Consequently, so far as I’m aware, there is yet no moderate Orthodox rabbi who knows how to pray from a Teimani Baladi Sidur.)

        A major problem is that Judaism, itself, has been going, and continues to go, through a significant period of introspection for the last century. Modern educated Orthodox Jews find Medieval superstitious “Judaism” impossible and incompatible. That, too, is something you’ll have to study and develop a working familiarity; becoming fluent in the nuances distinguishing various types of Ultra-Orthodox (including Khab”d and most “Orthodox shuls”), Orthodox (including moderate, Modern, nationalist, Zionist, etc.) and the continual proliferation of new versions of non-Orthodox and even irreligious Jews.

        The difficulties involved include many parts of the world still lacking a moderate Orthodox community, beit kᵊnesset and rabbi(s). (Even then, not all moderate Orthodox rabbis are up-to-date in their scholarship concerning the Nᵊtzarim.) “Conservative” Judaism means different things in different parts of the world. How all of these interrelate and why is essential to understand because you aim to become part of that community, know where you belong in that community and why.

        All of the answers to these questions, including developing your moderate Orthodox practice of Torah from Shabat to kashrut to praying, khagim and everything in-between, must come from a moderate Orthodox rabbi. In many parts of the world that’s still not possible. Even where there are moderate Orthodox communities and one or more moderate Orthodox rabbis, it is daunting to learn so much that is alien to non-Jews; especially learning to read, write, pray and at least communicate a little in Hebrew. But that’s your situation. Fortunately, Torah requires only that you do your utmost. So you must do your best to accomplish all of this beginning with relating to, and learning from, the Jewish communities available to you (and others, wherever they may live).


    • Wish we could. However, we’re only able to communicate fluently in English. With the infrequent help of a translator, we can hobble along in Hebrew. In the areas we discuss, Google Translator isn’t adequate to convey slight differences in meaning that can create enormous misunderstandings.


  4. שבת שלום פקיד i have 2 questions 1st what is Netzarim on Kararite teaching. 2nd does Netzarim have first post of call for person from church searching the website address? 3rd my wife and I will request gerim statue as Netzrim. This request must be in writing? I understand Netzrim do not do conversion this would be another step toward deeper Torah life commitment.


    • 1. There is only one right Way, which I’ve described extensively in my books and the Nᵊtzarim website ( Logic then excludes all others, which is an endless, and constantly growing, list. I determined decades ago that there is no future in getting sidetracked into dealing individually with each instance of an endless and growing list.

      2. In our Home Page—the Nᵊtzarim Gate (also depicted at the bottom of the navigation panel at left), there’s a Virtual Tour at the bottom of the last page of each section that guides you through our Virtual Village.

      3. For many years, it was essential to have a “hands on” denial of the countless Christian phonies who falsely claimed to be Nᵊtzarim. We’ve now well established for decades, in both the Jewish and Christian worlds, that there are no Nᵊtzarim in the Christian world and that it is impossible for a Christian (or a believer of the NT) to be a Nᵊtzarim. This, coupled with the basic understanding by a small number of moderate Orthodox rabbis that we are logical-halakhic moderate Orthodox Jews, makes it no longer necessary for me to personally recognize or deny who is intent on practicing logical-halakhic Torah-practice, as this small number of moderate Orthodox rabbis now do as well—and this is where future would-be Nᵊtzarim must seek acceptance. This is a weaning process. Future would-be Nᵊtzarim must publicly (not secretly) maintain Nᵊtzarim beliefs (as set forth in my books and while learning and conforming to the logical (!) aspects and practices in the moderate Orthodox Jewish community—via finding a modern-oriented and open-minded, moderate Orthodox rabbi who is sympathetic to your desire to practice Torah according to scientifically-logical halakhah. (It’s not an easy search. They’re still pretty rare.) It is impossible to practice Torah independent, or artificially separated, from the moderate Orthodox Jewish community.

      חג שמח


  5. שלום פקיד תמני סדור ץושה it have the different marks to represent the additional alef bet consients.


  6. When I go to NQ Iam having trouble scrolling down just opens on page. Not sure wether it is my problem or some thing at site. Has any one else had problem?


      • Didn’t know others were also having the problem. What browser(s) are yall using? Does a scroll bar display at the side? Are you getting both the white background navigation panel AND the blue Home Page? Or only one or the other?


      • ipads have this issue big time. on my laptop I use Firefox, I can scroll down but it is very narrow. I found I can right click what ever link I need to open in a new tab. But to go back to the original page I need to keep that open. Links from the opened tab do not have the menu on them.


    • Then you’re correct. However, it was unclear to whom you referred by “his.”

      I was thinking, later, about the term “Master” that you used. That’s not the term the נצרים use and it’s confusing (if not to you, then to readers), bringing up questions of the proper Hebrew: it’s unclear from the English whether you intended אֲדֹנָי, as Christians would assume and imply, or אֲדֹנִי — neither of which conforms to the examples in NQ, NHM and our other books and papers: ריבי יהושוע. It’s always risky for anyone not thoroughly acquainted with Orthodox Judaism to diverge from the paradigms given in NQ. You’re unaware of the strayings you may be initiating. I recommend not diverging from the lexicon paradigms in NQ; and certainly not when it perpetuates, or may appear to confirm, Christian (or Muslim) lexicon or perspective.


  7. In all this joy I feel and the path before me. It is disturbing to realise that Satan has since the 4th century masked him self in the image of the son of god to murder and accuse the children of HaShem quodesh echad the children of ישראל. It amazes me that the church of love is covered with the blood of Jewish children, forced conversions, and then drownings and burnings at the stake because they were judged not real converts. The madness is the madness of the anti christ. Not our beloved Master Yehoshua. His name and his love for HaShem quodesh echad should not be blasphemed by this satanic lie or his church.


    • You’re getting the gist correct. Some minor adjustments in spelling and terminology can be gleaned from further focus on the information and examples found in Some of your terminology is still Christian baggage not yet sloughed off. A point in your previous post: we eschew the assimilation of German and Hebrew (namely, Yiddish). I see loads of progress. One thing I don’t get, though, is the last phrase: “his church.” That’s an oxymoron. Keep up your study of NQ (the Netzarim Quarter, until you’ve absorbed and digested every page. If you don’t understand something in NQ, that’s a good question to clear up.


  8. This way can be difficult confusing. Looking for an ending.
    Or start a journey with life change copacity that is new everyday that never ends. Eachday we just rest at the end of each day. For the first time i see the time wasted. אתה ברוך ה שם אלינו מלך ה העולם אשר קדשנו במותו וצונו בקשו הדרך.


  9. It really is harder to post these things than it seems 2 ways life or death. I choose life and ha Shem’s quodesh echad way. 1 step at a time what a blessing. How blessed am I to realise we can all choose this journey.


  10. This way can be difficult confusing. Looking for an ending.
    Or start a journey with life change copacity that is new everyday that never ends each we just rest at the end of each day. For the first time i see the waste of time. אתה ברוך ה שם אלינו מלך ה העולם אשר קדשנו במותו וצונו בקשו הדרך.


    • Again, you’re distracted from your supposed practice of Torah to some irrelevant wild goose chase. Is solving this question somehow necessary to your weekly study of the weekly Torah portion in our Beit K’neset pages? To kashering your kitchen? Learning your Hebrew Nosakh Teimani liturgy? Concern yourself with how you should apply Torah in your personal practice and that will take up the rest of your life.


    • This is a public blog centered around Torah and Israel. If the question is something you’d rather not be public then the question isn’t appropriate for this blog. We discuss things that are peripheral to Torah and Israel like Torah outreach to people everywhere and how that trickles down to everything from morals to guns in a Torah-based society. If one is absorbed in learning and practicing Torah then I think this is where their questions will be. If this is not where their questions are then that’s evidence that they’re focused on the wrong thing(s) and need to refocus.


    • Perhaps; it seems he may have found his own way and he was certainly Torah observant. I didn’t know him personally. I’ve been approached by people offering to help anonymously. However, as a personal policy, I’ve always declined any kind of association with any anonymous person. No way to tell who you could be hooked up with and not know it.


  11. Do Netzarim tie 7 or 13 chuliot and what is the reasoning? I have heard 7 relates to 7 heavens and 13 to Hashem’s quodesh echad quodesh attibutes?


  12. I do apologise for the question on the eve of the khag. We were able to prepare in time. Is there realities we should be incorporating or should understand with upcoming khag. I am counting the omer each evening. Is there more?


    • It’s not possible, from far away, to notice how your practice may be differing from the basic practice of the moderate Orthodox Jewish community. The only way for you to discover that is to be in a close enough relationship with a moderate (not ultra) Orthodox Jewish community to notice how you may be doing some things differently from them. Then you can refer to my books and the Nᵊtzarim website ( to learn which way is Scriptural. Sometimes they make mistakes too; and in some ways many rabbis, even some moderate Orthodox rabbis, have strayed from Scripture.

      So, other than advising you to keep up with learning עברית, following the Judaic calendar (including the פרשות תורה) and what you learn in my books and the Nᵊtzarim website, only you can answer those questions by interacting, at some level (doesn’t mean you have to convert), with a moderate Orthodox Jewish community to see how your practice may differ.

      Good to hear that you’re counting the עמר. Keep up the good work.


  13. Could you speak on the Netzarim and the pasach is there documentation that the pasach was observed. Is there a tradition that would be a pliable or is the festival perfect.


    • Preparation for the Pesakh Seider and Khag ha-Matzot begin a couple of months before Pesakh, planning to reduce purchases of everything containing khameitz or s’or to run out of most before Khag ha-Matzot in order not to have to throw away a lot. At this late date, we’re all way too busy with our own preparations to write an article. Do what you can and get an earlier start next year. As soon as one khag is over you should be looking at what to begin preparing for next. Gotta get back to our own preparations.


  14. Could you speak about how we act in the face of the progressive left and atheistic governments with parallels to the Roman Empire of the past.


  15. Could you give your understanding of who homosexuality and the rasing of children by homosexuals and those openly discourage our grand children to to believe haShem quodesh echad exist. What is the torah communities halacha on this issue?


  16. Could you talk about the orthodoxy of the Torah community of the way. How can we live apply this here in diasapra.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s